top of page
  • Instagram
  • X
  • Black YouTube Icon
Search

How We'd Fix the UFC: Automatic Point Deductions, Weight-Miss Penalties & the Biggest UFC What Ifs

10 minutes ago
7 min read

No fight card this week means the gloves come off in a different way. With UFC Qatar still a few days out, Olin, Jive Turkey Nano and Pip went live on a Wednesday night episode of The MMAnomaly Show: No Filter with one simple premise: if we ran the UFC, what would we change? From weight-cut penalties and automatic point deductions to Pride-style first rounds and a belt every five pounds, the guys pitched their fixes round-robin style, then put on the tinfoil hats for the biggest "what ifs" in UFC history. Here are the ideas that won the panel, the ones that lost out and where it all goes next.

The MMAnomaly Show: No Filter thumbnail for How We'd Fix the UFC, UFC What Ifs and Overrated/Underrated Fighters, featuring hosts MMAnomaly, Jive Turkey Nano and Pipps Piano Tips

Biggest Winners

1. Fighters Who Fight Clean

The one idea nobody pushed back on. Pip's top fix was the foul system: no more warning culture. The first clear foul, whether it's an eye poke from extended fingers, a low blow that lands clean or a fence grab that changes the action, is an automatic point deduction. The second is another point, and a third puts disqualification on the table depending on severity. Pip's reasoning is simple: plenty of fighters go entire careers without a reputation for pokes and fence grabs, which proves clean habits are trainable, and intent shouldn't matter because the damage to the victim is the same. Olin had the exact same rule on his list. His comparison was the NFL: nobody debates whether a face-mask grab was intentional, the flag just gets thrown. The fighters hear the rules backstage before every fight, so treat them like professionals and take the point.

What's next? Pip also wants referees to stand fights up after roughly a minute of real inactivity on the ground, but to let grapplers work as long as they're advancing position or hunting submissions. Olin wants transparency on the other side of the cage: a pre-fight meeting where the judges for that night lay out how they're scoring, what counts as a significant strike and how they weigh grappling, so fighters and coaches know the rules of engagement going in.

2. Super-Fight Fans (and Belt Collectors)

Nano's pitch was the boldest of the night: a champion every five pounds. Win a second belt in the next division up while staying active and you earn a special platinum or diamond belt; collect three in a row, like 130, 135 and 140, and you're king of that whole stretch of the sport. Nano's view is that more belts means more unification fights, more super fights and more numbered-event headliners, and he floated a yearly Grand Prix-style "meta champion" on top of it all. Olin was in, with one condition: women would need more divisions too, all the way down to 105 and up through 135 or 140. He'd also add a super heavyweight division with no upper limit, which Nano loved for the marketing alone. Pip was split. He's for more divisions but worried about diluting the belt, pointing out that Amanda Nunes is really the only fighter who bounced between weight classes and defended both titles multiple times. For Pip, super fights like Alexander Volkanovski vs. Israel Adesanya felt like the Super Bowl precisely because both men had already cleaned out their own divisions.

What's next? Pip and the chat floated a 165-pound division to bridge lightweight and welterweight, and Nano wants the extra belts to bring back some of the cross-division gamesmanship he grew up with in boxing.

3. Pride Nostalgia

Olin's final rule change was a throwback: a 10-minute first round followed by two five-minute rounds, the old Pride format. For championship fights, a 15-minute first round followed by three five-minute rounds. No break means real cardio, real game planning and a real incentive to get the finish early if you aren't conditioned to go the distance. Pip wasn't calling Olin crazy. He expects more first-round finishes and fewer fighters trying to overwhelm their opponent and gas out. He was far less excited about the chat's suggestion of shorter three-minute rounds, siding with Miss Mary's take that three minutes isn't enough time to build a rhythm in a sport with this many weapons.

What's next? Nano's one caveat: longer rounds only work if referees are clearly empowered to step in when the action stalls, which loops right back to the panel's push for officiating standards and transparency.

Biggest Losers

1. Fighters Who Miss Weight

Olin opened the show with a sliding-scale penalty for weight misses. Right now, depending on the commission, a fighter who misses gives up 20 or 30 percent of their purse. Under Olin's clause, you still pay that, and every additional pound over adds 10 percent, taken from both show money and win money. The timing couldn't be better. At UFC 334, Terrance McKinney weighed in at 160.2 pounds, 4.2 over the lightweight limit, then knocked out Jim Miller in 1:53 of the first round. Olin's point is that a flat fine doesn't hurt enough, and someone who misses by Khamzat Chimaev's 7.5 pounds at UFC 279 should pay far more than someone who misses by a pound and a half. Nano would pass that vote. Pip went further: an immediate point deduction to start the fight on top of the fine, more hydration testing and possibly licensing fighters by their walking weight, so nobody can drop two full divisions without medical clearance. As Pip put it, some weight management is fine, but nearly killing yourself in a sauna and rehydrating bigger than your opponent is not, and the UFC has the money to fix it after a $7.7 billion deal with Paramount.

What's next? McKinney has already said he's moving up to welterweight. Olin's question for the comments: what's your weight-miss penalty?

2. The Oblique Kick

Joe Rogan recently said on his podcast that the oblique kick is about to be outlawed. As of now, no commission or rules body has made that official: the kick is still legal under the Unified Rules, although California State Athletic Commission director Andy Foster has pushed for a ban and Dana White has said the UFC agrees. Olin called it a double-edged sword. He admits obliques can end careers, and he pointed to Shavkat Rakhmonov's knee as an example when the chat claimed no career has ever been hurt by one. But his bigger issue is priorities: fix the fouls that already exist before banning techniques fighters have trained for years. Ban it, and veterans will use it to cheat while newer fighters won't train to defend it.

What's next? For now, it's legal at UFC Qatar. Olin, for the record, would rather bring back soccer kicks to a grounded opponent.

3. Michael Chandler, in the Timeline That Never Was

Pip's alternate-universe pick was Conor McGregor vs. Michael Chandler. The two coached opposite each other on The Ultimate Fighter, the animosity was real and the fight was set for UFC 303 before McGregor withdrew. Pip's biggest takeaway is how much it cost Chandler, who spent about two years of his prime waiting on McGregor instead of building more of a UFC legacy. Nano thinks a motivated, in-shape McGregor would have won, since Chandler leaves himself open and nearly everyone he's faced has hurt him. Olin disagreed: that version of McGregor was depleted, and he thinks Chandler would have beaten him up at 155 or 170.

What's next? Nano had the best line on the fight: the press conferences alone would have fed families.

Other Notable What Ifs

  • Khabib Nurmagomedov vs. Tony Ferguson. Pip's biggest what if. The fight was booked five times and fell through every time, including Ferguson's knee injury after tripping over a cable and the UFC 249 collapse in 2020. Pip says a Ferguson win reshapes the entire post-Khabib lightweight landscape. Nano thinks Ferguson cuts him and makes him bleed, and Olin agrees, but both expect Khabib to get the takedowns and smash him anyway.

  • Fedor Emelianenko vs. the UFC. Nano went with Jon Jones vs. Fedor, with Jones vs. Francis Ngannou as the modern version. Olin countered with Cain Velasquez or Daniel Cormier vs. Fedor, and said he'd rather see Jones vs. Tom Aspinall than Jones vs. Ngannou. Pip and Olin agree: Fedor and Cain are their heavyweight GOATs.

  • What if Jorge Masvidal's flying knee misses Ben Askren? Olin's pick for the "dankest timeline." No five-second knockout means a very different Masvidal story and maybe a different welterweight title picture. Pip thinks we got Askren far too late, but still sees Kamaru Usman becoming champion either way. Nano believes Masvidal would have hurt him eventually anyway. Olin thinks Askren grinds out a bloody win, beats Stephen Thompson and then gets Usman, before winning the title and retiring immediately.

  • What if the Fertittas never hired Dana White? Nano's what if. The panel agreed that without the Fertittas' money there's no UFC, and without White pitching The Ultimate Fighter, there's no Stephan Bonner vs. Forrest Griffin moment to launch the sport into the mainstream.

  • What if Charles Oliveira didn't grab gloves against Dustin Poirier? Olin thinks Poirier hurt Oliveira early at UFC 269 and would have won without the fouls. Nano thinks Poirier wins six or seven out of ten. Pip gives credit to Oliveira's grappling, but agrees that with better officiating, the night could have ended differently.

Looking Ahead

The overrated/underrated segment will have to wait for another night, because UFC Qatar is on deck this Saturday with Jiří Procházka vs. Navajo Stirling in the main event and Aljamain Sterling vs. Kevin Vallejos in the co-main. The guys gave an early look at their bets: a three-leg parlay of Kyoji Horiguchi, Aleksandre Topuria and Aljamain Sterling as the underdog, which they had at roughly +331. Full breakdowns are coming in our UFC Qatar predictions and best bets. Let us know in the comments: what's your biggest UFC what if, and if you were the new boss in town, how would you fix the UFC? Stay tuned…

 
 
 

Comments


© 2024 MMAnomaly. All Rights Reserved
© MMAnomaly est 2020 | MMAnomaly Show: No Filter

bottom of page